The 8 Human Motivations (And Why Your Product Only Needs 2)

Here's a question that will change how you build products:

What actually makes users come back?

Most founders answer with features:

"Our AI personalization..."
"Our seamless onboarding..."
"Our robust analytics..."

Wrong answer.

Users don't come back for features.

They come back because your product satisfies a fundamental human need.

And there are only 8 of them.

The Problem With "Comprehensive"

Every product pitch I hear sounds the same:

"We help users track their goals, collaborate with teams, express creativity, build community, achieve mastery, find their purpose, gain status, and feel secure."

Translation:

"We're trying to be everything to everyone, which means we'll be mediocre at all of it and die in 18 months."

Here's the truth nobody wants to hear:

Your product can't satisfy all human needs.

Not because you're a bad founder.

Because it's psychologically impossible.

Some motivations contradict each other.

Some require completely different features.

Some attract totally different users.

Trying to serve all 8 is how you end up serving none.

The 8 Human Motivations

After analyzing hundreds of successful products, I've identified 8 core psychological drivers that keep users engaged:

🎯 Purpose - "I want meaning"
📈 Progress - "I want to improve"
🎨 Creativity - "I want to express myself"
👑 Ownership - "This is mine"
🤝 Connection - "I want to belong"
💎 Exclusivity - "I want status"
🔍 Curiosity - "I want discovery"
🛡️ Security - "I want safety"

Every product decision you make either strengthens or weakens these motivations.

And here's the kicker:

The most successful products dominate 2-3 and completely ignore the rest.

Let me show you each one—and prove why you can't (and shouldn't) try to master them all.

1. 🎯 PURPOSE

"I want to make a meaningful impact"

What It Is:

Purpose-driven users want to feel like their actions contribute to something bigger than themselves.

Not "I want to have fun."

"I want to change the world."

Core Psychology:

Humans have an innate need for meaning. We want our lives—and our actions—to matter.

Products that tap into Purpose give users a sense that every action is meaningful.

How It Shows Up in Products:

Duolingo:
"Learn a language, change your life"
→ Every lesson = Progress toward a life goal

Charity Miles:
"Every step you take raises money for causes"
→ Walking = Helping others

Khan Academy:
"Free education for anyone, anywhere"
→ Learning = Democratizing knowledge

TOMS Shoes:
"One for One - buy shoes, give shoes"
→ Purchase = Social impact

Ecosia:
"The search engine that plants trees"
→ Searching = Environmental action

Key Features:

✅ Mission-driven messaging
✅ Impact metrics ("You've helped plant 47 trees!")
✅ Connection to causes or values
✅ Personalization ("Why are YOU doing this?")
✅ Real-world outcomes displayed

Who Responds to Purpose:

• Social impact seekers
• Cause-driven individuals
• People in self-improvement phases
• Those seeking life meaning
• Altruistic personalities

When to Use Purpose:

• Education products
• Health/wellness apps
• Sustainability products
• Non-profit platforms
• Personal development tools

When NOT to Use Purpose:

If your product is purely entertainment, utility, or professional tools—forcing "purpose" feels preachy and performative.

Notion doesn't pretend you're changing the world by organizing notes.

And that's perfectly fine.

2. 📈 PROGRESS

"I want to get better"

What It Is:

Progress-driven users are motivated by visible improvement, achievement, and mastery.

Not "I want to do things."

"I want to do things BETTER."

Core Psychology:

Humans are hardwired to seek growth. We're happiest when we're improving.

Products that tap into Progress make every action feel like forward momentum.

How It Shows Up in Products:

Strava:
Personal records, segment leaderboards, monthly goals
→ Every run compares to your best

Duolingo:
Streaks, XP, leagues, skill trees
→ Daily visible progress toward fluency

LinkedIn:
Profile strength meter, skill endorsements, connection milestones
→ Your network = Your professional growth

Headspace:
Days meditated, total minutes, course completion
→ Mental health = Measurable improvement

Grammarly:
Weekly writing stats, vocabulary score, productivity metrics
→ Writing skill = Tracked over time

Key Features:

✅ Metrics and tracking (XP, points, stats)
✅ Streaks and consistency rewards
✅ Leaderboards and rankings
✅ Before/after comparisons
✅ Milestones and achievements
✅ Visual progress bars

Who Responds to Progress:

• Competitive personalities
• Self-improvement enthusiasts
• Data-driven decision makers
• Goal-oriented achievers
• Anyone learning a skill

When to Use Progress:

• Fitness apps
• Learning platforms
• Productivity tools
• Skill-building products
• Habit trackers

Why It's Addictive:

Progress is measurable and visible.

You can't see yourself "getting healthier" in real-time.

But you can see "47-day streak" grow to "48-day streak."

The abstraction becomes concrete.

The Dark Side:

Progress motivation can become obsessive.

Users chase metrics even when they're no longer meaningful.

(Strava users doing midnight runs just to maintain streaks)

Use responsibly.

3. 🎨 CREATIVITY

"I want to express myself"

What It Is:

Creativity-driven users want to make something unique, personal, and expressive.

Not "I want to use a tool."

"I want to create MY thing."

Core Psychology:

Humans have a fundamental need for self-expression. We want to externalize our internal world.

Products that tap into Creativity give users infinite canvas for self-expression.

How It Shows Up in Products:

Notion:
Blank pages, unlimited customization, templates, databases
→ Your workspace = Your rules

Instagram:
Filters, editing tools, stories, reels
→ Your photos = Your aesthetic

Minecraft:
Unlimited blocks, no rules, pure creation
→ Your world = Your vision

Canva:
Templates + customization tools
→ Your designs = Professional + personal

Figma:
Infinite canvas, design systems, components
→ Your mockups = Pixel-perfect expression

Key Features:

✅ Customization options
✅ Blank canvas experiences
✅ Templates as starting points
✅ Personalization everywhere
✅ User-generated content
✅ Visual expression tools

Who Responds to Creativity:

• Artists and designers
• Writers and creators
• Anyone who values aesthetics
• People who hate "one-size-fits-all"
• Self-expression seekers

When to Use Creativity:

• Design tools
• Content creation platforms
• Productivity apps (if customization matters)
• Social media
• Gaming

The Trade-Off:

Creativity and Progress often conflict.

Notion: Infinite customization, but no streaks or XP

Duolingo: Tons of progress tracking, but zero customization

You can't have both at 10/10.

If you let users customize everything, you can't have fair leaderboards.

If you enforce rigid structures for progress tracking, creativity dies.

Pick one.

4. 👑 OWNERSHIP

"This is mine"

What It Is:

Ownership-driven users are motivated by possession, control, and investment.

Not "I'm using this tool."

"This is MY tool."

Core Psychology:

The Endowment Effect: We value things more once we own them.

Products that tap into Ownership make users feel like they've invested in something that's theirs.

How It Shows Up in Products:

Notion:
"Your workspace" - all data belongs to you
→ Years of notes = Too valuable to leave

Robinhood:
"Your portfolio" - you own these stocks
→ Real money invested = Real ownership

Animal Crossing:
"Your island" - you built this world
→ Hundreds of hours invested = Can't abandon it

Substack:
"Your newsletter, your subscribers"
→ You own the audience, not the platform

Evernote:
"Your notes" - decades of personal data
→ Switching = Losing your digital brain

Key Features:

✅ Data ownership and export
✅ Personalization that persists
✅ Long-term investment mechanics
✅ "Your [thing]" messaging
✅ Accumulated value over time
✅ Portability and control

Who Responds to Ownership:

• People who value autonomy
• Long-term thinkers
• Those who hate vendor lock-in
• Collectors and hoarders
• Privacy-conscious users

When to Use Ownership:

• Productivity tools
• Note-taking apps
• Finance products
• Creative platforms
• Any tool where users invest significant time/data

The Lock-In Effect:

Ownership creates the strongest retention.

Switching cost = abandoning YOUR stuff.

Notion users have years of notes.

Strava users have years of workout history.

Robinhood users have real money invested.

Leaving means losing ownership.

This is intentional design.

5. 🤝 CONNECTION

"I want to belong"

What It Is:

Connection-driven users are motivated by relationships, community, and social belonging.

Not "I want to do things alone."

"I want to do things WITH people."

Core Psychology:

Humans are tribal. We're happiest when we're part of a group.

Products that tap into Connection make users feel like they're never alone.

How It Shows Up in Products:

Strava:
Activity feed, kudos, local leaderboards
→ Your workout = Social event

Peloton:
Live classes, high-fives, leaderboard during rides
→ Solo workout = Community experience

Discord:
Servers, channels, voice chat
→ Your interests = Your community

Duolingo (weakly):
Leagues with random users
→ Learning = Mild social competition

Instagram:
Following, likes, comments, DMs
→ Your life = Shared with your network

Key Features:

✅ Activity feeds
✅ Social recognition (likes, kudos, comments)
✅ Lightweight interaction
✅ Community spaces
✅ Shared experiences
✅ Friend/follower systems

Who Responds to Connection:

• Extroverts
• Community-oriented people
• Those who value relationships
• Social sharers
• Anyone motivated by others' opinions

When to Use Connection:

• Social networks (obviously)
• Fitness apps
• Gaming
• Learning platforms (study groups)
• Any activity better with others

The Paradox:

Too much Connection can destroy other motivations.

If Notion added social feeds: Your workspace becomes performative, not productive

If Duolingo added chat: Learning gets distracted by socializing

Connection is powerful. But it's invasive.

Use it only if social belonging is CORE to your value prop.

6. 💎 EXCLUSIVITY

"I want status"

What It Is:

Exclusivity-driven users are motivated by rarity, status, and being part of an elite group.

Not "I want what everyone has."

"I want what most people can't have."

Core Psychology:

Humans are status-seeking animals. We want to signal our value to others.

Products that tap into Exclusivity make users feel like they're part of something special.

How It Shows Up in Products:

Superhuman:
Invite-only, $30/month, onboarding call required
→ Email client = Status symbol

Clubhouse (at launch):
Invite-only audio rooms
→ Early access = Social currency

American Express Black Card:
Invitation required, $10k/year fee
→ Credit card = Elite status

Supreme:
Limited drops, sold out in seconds
→ Clothing = Exclusivity badge

Tesla (early days):
Waitlists, limited production
→ Car = Tech elite identifier

Key Features:

✅ Invite-only access
✅ Waitlists
✅ Premium tiers with clear differentiation
✅ Limited availability
✅ Status badges/indicators
✅ VIP experiences

Who Responds to Exclusivity:

• Status-conscious individuals
• Early adopters
• Luxury consumers
• Those seeking differentiation
• People motivated by scarcity

When to Use Exclusivity:

• Premium products
• Luxury services
• Early-stage launches (to create buzz)
• High-end B2B tools
• Membership communities

The Risk:

Exclusivity conflicts with Purpose and Connection.

Can't change the world if only elites can access your product.

Can't build community if you're intentionally keeping people out.

Superhuman chose Exclusivity over Connection.

Duolingo chose Purpose over Exclusivity.

Both are billion-dollar companies.

Because they chose.

7. 🔍 CURIOSITY

"I want discovery"

What It Is:

Curiosity-driven users are motivated by novelty, surprise, and exploration.

Not "I know what I'll find."

"I wonder what's next."

Core Psychology:

Humans are curious by nature. The unknown triggers dopamine.

Products that tap into Curiosity make users feel like there's always something new to discover.

How It Shows Up in Products:

TikTok:
Infinite scroll, algorithm-driven content
→ Every swipe = New surprise

Spotify Discover Weekly:
Fresh playlist every Monday
→ New music you'll actually like

Netflix:
"Because you watched..." recommendations
→ Endless content discovery

Product Hunt:
New products daily
→ Tomorrow's tools today

Reddit:
Infinite subreddits to explore
→ There's always a new rabbit hole

Key Features:

✅ Algorithm-driven recommendations
✅ "Explore" sections
✅ Randomization and surprise
✅ Infinite scroll
✅ Discovery feeds
✅ Variable rewards

Who Responds to Curiosity:

• Information seekers
• Content consumers
• Early adopters
• People who love novelty
• Exploratory personalities

When to Use Curiosity:

• Content platforms
• Discovery apps
• News aggregators
• Entertainment products
• Exploration-based tools

The Danger:

Curiosity is the least "sticky" motivation.

Users explore... then leave.

TikTok combats this with addictive algorithms.

Netflix combats this with original content.

Spotify combats this with personalization.

Curiosity alone = High engagement, low retention.

You need a second motivation to create lock-in.

8. 🛡️ SECURITY

"I want safety"

What It Is:

Security-driven users are motivated by trust, safety, and risk reduction.

Not "I want new and exciting."

"I want reliable and safe."

Core Psychology:

Humans are risk-averse. We want to protect what we have.

Products that tap into Security make users feel safe, protected, and in control.

How It Shows Up in Products:

1Password:
"Your passwords, secured"
→ Digital safety tool

Mint:
"Know where your money goes"
→ Financial clarity = Security

LastPass:
"Never lose a password"
→ Protection from chaos

Norton:
"Antivirus protection"
→ Threat prevention

Life360:
"Know your family is safe"
→ Location tracking for peace of mind

Key Features:

✅ Privacy controls
✅ Data encryption
✅ Backup and recovery
✅ Trust signals (certifications, testimonials)
✅ Transparency in operations
✅ Risk mitigation messaging

Who Responds to Security:

• Risk-averse individuals
• Parents
• Enterprise buyers
• Privacy-conscious users
• Anyone burned by security issues before

When to Use Security:

• Password managers
• Finance apps
• Healthcare products
• Enterprise SaaS
• Products handling sensitive data

The Challenge:

Security is rarely someone's PRIMARY motivation.

It's a baseline expectation, not a driver.

Nobody opens 1Password thinking "I'm so excited about security!"

They open it because they need it to function safely.

Security prevents users from leaving. It rarely attracts them in the first place.

PART 2: WHY YOU CAN'T MASTER ALL 8

Now that you know the 8 motivations, here's why you can't (and shouldn't) try to nail them all:

Reason #1: Some Motivations Contradict Each Other

Progress vs Creativity:
Progress requires structure, tracking, and standardization.

Creativity requires freedom, customization, and chaos.

You can't have both at 10/10.

Duolingo: Structured lessons, zero customization (Progress > Creativity)

Notion: Infinite canvas, no progress tracking (Creativity > Progress)

Purpose vs Exclusivity:
Purpose says "change the world for everyone."

Exclusivity says "this is only for the elite."

You can't have both at 10/10.

Duolingo: Free for everyone (Purpose > Exclusivity)

Superhuman: $30/month invite-only (Exclusivity > Purpose)

Connection vs Security:
Connection requires sharing and openness.

Security requires privacy and control.

You can't have both at 10/10.

Instagram: Share everything publicly (Connection > Security)

Signal: Encrypted private messaging (Security > Connection)

Reason #2: Different Users Want Different Motivations

Progress users hate lack of structure.

Creativity users hate rigid systems.

Purpose users want meaning.

Curiosity users want novelty.

If you try to serve all 8, you'll build features that:

• Confuse half your users
• Dilute your core experience
• Create internal contradictions
• Satisfy nobody fully

Reason #3: Every Feature Has a Cost

Adding a social feed (Connection) means:

❌ More complex UI (hurts simplicity)
❌ Moderation required (operational cost)
❌ Privacy concerns (hurts Security)
❌ Performance hit (technical debt)

Adding customization (Creativity) means:

❌ Can't have fair leaderboards (hurts Progress)
❌ Harder onboarding (hurts adoption)
❌ More bugs (technical complexity)
❌ Confused new users (UX debt)

Every feature you add to serve a new motivation weakens something else.

PART 3: THE 2-3 RULE

Here's the pattern behind every successful product:

Pick 2-3 motivations. Dominate them. Ignore the rest.

Notion: Creativity + Ownership

✅ Creativity (10/10): Infinite customization
✅ Ownership (10/10): Your workspace, your data
❌ Progress (2/10): No streaks, no XP
❌ Connection (2/10): Minimal social
❌ Purpose (3/10): No mission
❌ Exclusivity (2/10): Free for everyone
❌ Curiosity (4/10): No discovery feed
❌ Security (5/10): Basic, not emphasized

Result: 30M users who can't imagine working any other way

Strava: Progress + Connection

✅ Progress (10/10): PRs, leaderboards, streaks
✅ Connection (10/10): Social feed, kudos, rankings
❌ Creativity (2/10): Can't customize
❌ Ownership (4/10): Limited personalization
❌ Purpose (3/10): No mission
❌ Exclusivity (2/10): Free tier
❌ Curiosity (3/10): No discovery
❌ Security (4/10): Not emphasized

Result: 120M users who chose Strava over better hardware

Duolingo: Progress + Purpose

✅ Progress (10/10): Streaks, XP, leagues
✅ Purpose (10/10): Life-changing language skills
❌ Creativity (1/10): Rigid structure
❌ Ownership (3/10): Can't customize
❌ Connection (3/10): Minimal social
❌ Exclusivity (1/10): Free for all
❌ Curiosity (4/10): Linear path
❌ Security (4/10): Not relevant

Result: 500M users guilt-tripped by an owl

Superhuman: Exclusivity + Progress

✅ Exclusivity (10/10): Invite-only, $30/month
✅ Progress (9/10): Inbox Zero tracking
❌ Creativity (4/10): Limited customization
❌ Ownership (5/10): Gmail-dependent
❌ Connection (2/10): Email is private
❌ Purpose (4/10): No mission
❌ Curiosity (3/10): Just email
❌ Security (6/10): Basic privacy

Result: $60M ARR from email

See the pattern?

Winners score 9-10/10 on 2-3 motivations.

They score 1-4/10 on everything else.

And they're fine with that.

PART 4: HOW TO FIND YOUR 2-3

Step 1: Audit Your Current Product

Rate yourself honestly on all 8:

🎯 Purpose: __/10
📈 Progress: __/10
🎨 Creativity: __/10
👑 Ownership: __/10
🤝 Connection: __/10
💎 Exclusivity: __/10
🔍 Curiosity: __/10
🛡️ Security: __/10

If you're 6/10 across the board, you're generic.

Step 2: Ask Your Best Users WHY They Stay

Interview 10 power users:

"What would you lose if this product disappeared tomorrow?"

Their answers will reveal which motivations actually matter.

If they say:

"My workout history" → Ownership + Progress
"The community" → Connection
"The customization" → Creativity
"The streak" → Progress
"The status" → Exclusivity

Step 3: Look at Your Competitors' Weaknesses

Where are they weak?

If everyone in your space is 8/10 at Progress but 2/10 at Connection...

Maybe you should be 10/10 at Connection.

Find the gap. Own it.

Step 4: Pick Your 2-3 and Commit

This is the hardest part.

You have to say no to good ideas that serve the wrong motivations.

"Let's add a social feed!" → Does it strengthen your spine? No? Say no.

"Let's add customization!" → Does it strengthen your spine? No? Say no.

"Let's add streaks!" → Does it strengthen your spine? No? Say no.

Every feature is a vote for a motivation.

Vote for the same 2-3 every time.

PART 5: THE HARD TRUTH

Most products fail because founders can't make this choice.

They want to be:

✅ Meaningful (Purpose)
✅ Trackable (Progress)
✅ Customizable (Creativity)
✅ Personal (Ownership)
✅ Social (Connection)
✅ Exclusive (Exclusivity)
✅ Novel (Curiosity)
✅ Secure (Security)

So they build a Frankenstein product that's mediocre at everything.

And they wonder why users churn.

The winners?

They make the hard choice.

Notion chose Creativity over Progress.

Strava chose Connection over Creativity.

Duolingo chose Progress over Ownership.

Superhuman chose Exclusivity over Purpose.

And they became billion-dollar companies.

Because they chose.

Your Turn

What are YOUR 2-3 motivations?

Which will you dominate?

Which will you ignore?

---

Related Reading:

• Why Do 95% of Apps Fail? (It's Not What You Think)
• Duolingo's Secret: How 500M Users Got Addicted to Learning